Once more Ellie Chalkley gets behind the customs desk to welcome another visitor to the Île de Bezençon, judge their record selections, and ponder their luxury.
This week we’re visited by Jon Jacob, to talk about music theory, obsolete VHS collections, Jesus Christ Superstar and occasionally a Eurovision song or two.
Keep listening to the ESC Insight podcast as the new season gathers pace for more Eurovision news, fun, and chat. You’ll find the show in iTunes, and a direct RSS feed is also available. We also have a regular email newsletter which you can sign up to here.
“We have experienced some problems with the online voting, but we are checking.”
With those words from the EBU’s Gert Kark, the popular story of the Junior Eurovision Song Contest 2017 was set. No matter the challenging nature of the Russian song, the return of Portugal after ten years, or the very first key-change in any Australian Eurovision entry, Tbilisi will forever be ‘the Contest where online voting failed.’
How Can It Be A Success If It Failed?
I’m not going to minimise the impact of the online voting issues, that’s a hefty weight on one side of the scales. But I want to look at the other side and propose that the EBU made the correct decision to implement an online voting system, that it was beneficial to Junior Eurovision, and it was perfectly in keeping with the ideals and aims of the Eurovision Song Contest brand.
That said, it probably needs at least another year of testing before it can even be considered for the Adult Contest.
Where Did We Start From
It’s worth looking at the conditions that the EBU faced in gathering a public vote for 2017’s Junior Eurovision Song Contest. Two countries were broadcasting the show on time delay (Ireland and Australia, although if you wanted to get up at oh-my-god-its-early Down Under then you could watch the clean feed being relayed on ABC.me) so the traditional phone/text window was not possible. Even if it was used by the rest of the entrants, the lower viewing figures in some countries meant that getting enough valid votes to protect the integrity of the results by passing the various thresholds was challenging at best. Junior Eurovision 2016’s experiment with three juries and no public component to the vote left a bad taste… this is a show that is meant to be inclusive. That includes being inclusive of those watching in coutnries which did not have an entry.
Given those limitations a move to the internet for an online vote was the best answer.
The challenge comes in deciding how you identify the voters and audit for multiple vote casting (either by accident, by experimentation, or with more forethought). This is a challenge for any online voting system. Some broadcasters use a social media login (typically via Facebook) to identify voters. Other ask for an account to be created with the broadcaster and users must sign in (The BBC has such as system to cast your votes on Strictly Come Dancing). These are more secure but demand more time and patience from the voter.
Although the EBU has access to its own social network (myeurovision.tv), and the Eurovision events have significant presence on Facebook, the voting system instead used other methods of tracking so that “only one vote was counted from a single device.” We understand that the time to process votes through this security system held up the vote during the show.
The High Wire Nature Of Live Broadcasting
Nothing ever works one hundred percent on a live show. Both Lisa-Jayne, Tony Currie, and I know where the mistakes, the flaws, the changed scripts, and missed opportunities were in our live radio broadcast of the show. No doubt the TV production of Junior Eurovision has a similar list. Voting is one of them.
But you practice for failure and you make sure you have many options. In the case of the online voting, the EBU could still count the votes that were successfully cast during the show. Depending on the number of connected sessions to the voting server compared to the votes cast you can have a good idea how many are uncounted. Given the number of votes cast its likely these will be in roughly the same proportions.
You never want a blank monitor during a broadcast, but you practice in case it happens (image: Ewan Spence)
Live broadcasts always have fallback positions for pretty much every system. They are discussed in advance because you ”plan for failure’. For example, with the vote starting on Friday and closing on Sunday as the show started there was a set of online votes already locked in and presumably printed out to be used if required. If the online voting system had went down completely during the show it would have been embarrassing but there would still have been a valid vote that had been running for 46 hours.
You hope not to use them, but they are there. The key phrase in Tbilisi was not ‘there was a problem’ but ‘we have a valid vote’.
What Did Work?
Rather than a fifteen minute window of voting, the 2017 Junior Eurovision Song Contest saw the delegations, performers, and the fans all start pushing hard for votes and recognition from Friday 6pm CET before the Contest. That offered two days of increased social media presence, a call to action to every fan of the Contest, and alerting the fanbase of every performer that they were taking to the international stage.
Junior Eurovision became a longer experience, even though the show was, curiously, one of the shortest Song Contests of the last decade. It remains to be seen just how much of an impact this had on viewing figures – although they are down would they have been down more without two days of online push – but there was an increase in awareness. That awareness was worldwide, which meant that voting and participation as not restricted to the sixteen countries in the Contest, but everyone who wanted to watch online (assuming the show wasn’t geo-blocked in their country for complicated musical licensing reasons).
Polina Bogusevich and the Junior Eurovision trophy (EBU/Thomas Hanses)
Media consumption habits are changing. Everyone tuning in at once for a single program is no longer the norm. While competitive events such as the Eurovision Song Contest remain as appointment viewing, opening up the voting window allowed people to consume part of the show on demand and according to their own schedule.
That does diminish the impact of the live show, as previously discussed here on ESC Insight, but is that loss balanced out against the online gains?
Eurovision is not just a four-hour show in May (or a two-hour show in November). The contest within the contest that is Eurovision already relies heavily on PR and marketing, there’s a need to have an efficient ‘get the vote out’ system, and its about leveraging a delegations limited resources to create the most buzz online to capture attention as the voting starts. This year’s online voting at Junior Eurovision has simply codified the long game into the rule book. It’s clear that some delegations had worked through the game theory of winning Junior Eurovision more than others.
Marcel Bezençon Would Be Proud
One of the guiding principles given to the Eurovision Song Contest from its father, Marcel Bezençon, was its use as a test-bed of new technology (alongside bringing countries closer together and the ability to share cultures). There’s no doubt that this year’s Junior Eurovision accomplished all three, but the use of online voting is a clear nod towards using the Contest as a platform to test new technology for the benefit of all of the EBU’s members.
You have to remember that computer code is hard to write, and testing it before deployment is even harder. There was clearly an issue with part of the online voting system during Junior Eurovision 2017. Let’s acknowledge that a mistake was made, but let’s also acknowledge that the introduction of online voting addressed many concerns of Junior Eurovision fans, has given the EBU and its broadcasting members a significant amount of data regarding engagement and participation, and reminds everyone that the Junior Eurovision Song Contest sits at the cutting edge of live television.
That was the Junior Eurovision Song Contest that was. Russia’s Polina Bogusevich is the first winner of the brand new JESC Trophy. ‘Wings’ scored 188 points, narrowly beating the entry from our Geogian hosts.
Jut before boarding their flights home, Ewan and Lisa-Jayne look back at the Grand Final and the performances, discuss the issues surrounding the online vote, and wonder if they will ever be allowed to attend another Festivali i Kenges.
Eurovision Insight Podcast: The Final Podcast From Tbilisi, Monday 27th November
Ewan Spence and Lisa-Jayne Lewis review last night’s Grand Final and look back at the Junior Eurovision Song Contest 2017, in our final podcast from Tbilisi.
Remember to stay up to date with all the results from the world of the Eurovision Song Contest by subscribing to the ESC Insight podcast for our daily podcasts. You’ll find the show in iTunes, and a direct RSS feed is also available. We also have a regular email newsletter which you can sign up to here.
The Maltese performance features detailing taken from the worlds of audio-visual technology. There’ll be a detailed rendition of a loudspeaker, an assortment of stylish vintage televisions and for fans of television testcards an appearance of the classic PM 5544.
Boys on stage!?
From our 16 competing countries, we have solo lead vocals from a grand total of three boys. Let’s hear it for Misha, Gianluca and Grigol! Fans of the adorable junior boyband aesthetic will be glad to see that the Netherlands are attempting to put more boys on stage than ever before, with incredibly professional and enthusiastic archetypal boyband Fource.
A Hauntingly Familiar Duo
When Serbia take to the stage, you might find yourself thinking about cake-related puns because Irina and Jana are the contest’s very own mini Mel and Sue.
To Touch The Tree or Not Touch The Tree?
In a nod to all fans of running order jokes and fans of trees on the Eurovision stage, the Albanian singer Ana Kodra’s firm instruction to not touch the tree will be followed up by the Ukrainian performers not just touching the tree, but sitting in it.
Return of the Hoverboard
You might think that after being the Christmas gift of the year in 2016 and featuring heavily in last year’s Junior Eurovision, we might be done with the wheeled devices that falsely advertise themselves as hoverboards. We are not. But you might not recognise it with the shiny new and rather antipodean livery.
One of the unifying factors for all Europeans from the Straits of Gibraltar to the Sami lands, from the Irish Gaeltacht to the furthest eastern Caucasus is the sight of cheerful Ikea furniture. This year, we’ll even have some on stage at Junior.
Where the Saperavi Comes From
This year’s postcards showcase Georgian landmarks and tourism opportunities. Continuing the theme of wine being central to Georgian cultural identity, and also very tasty, our favourite one showcases a beautiful, fruitful vineyard.
One of our favourite performances is enhanced by a video projection that is entirely in in the ESC Insight colours of black, white and gold. We didn’t pre-arrange this, but we’re happy to see it.
Start the Fans Please!
There’s an impressive wind machine effect that Carola would be jealous of – you’ll know it when you see it.
The Junior Eurovision Song Contest 2017 will be broadcast on Sunday 26th November beginning at 1545 CET / 1445pm GMT. Go to www.radiosix.com to check listings.
Recorded rather late on the night before the Grand Final of the Junior Eurovision Song Contest 2017, Ewan, Lisa, Richard, and Luke consider the impressive performances of the Jury Final and what you should watch out for during the live show.
…and there’s not a bus in sight during this cast…
Eurovision Insight Podcast: Daily News From Tbilisi, Sunday 26th November
Ewan Spence, Lisa-Jayne Lewis, Luke Giles, and Richard Taylor review the Jury Final of JESC 2017 and preview the Grand Final in today’s coverage of the Junior Eurovision Song Contest 2017.
Remember to stay up to date with all the results from Junior Eurovision by subscribing to the ESC Insight podcast for our daily podcasts. You’ll find the show in iTunes, and a direct RSS feed is also available. We also have a regular email newsletter which you can sign up to here.
The final technical rehearsals have taken place, with only the dress rehearsals of the show for our performers to have their final moments on the stage. We look back at the latest tweaks of nine countries, as well as interview Australia’s new host, and crash into Georgia’s Pop Idol franchise to meet a former Song Contest singer.
Eurovision Insight Podcast: Daily News From Tbilisi, Saturday 25th November
Ewan Spence, Lisa-Jayne Lewis, and Brent Davison recap the final rehearsals, talk to more of the stars, and gatecrash Georgia’s Pop Idol in today’s coverage of the Junior Eurovision Song Contest 2017. Read more on the Eurovision Song Contest and Junior Eurovision from ESC Insight at www.escinsight.com.
Remember to stay up to date with all the Junior Eurovision news by subscribing to the ESC Insight podcast for our daily podcasts. You’ll find the show in iTunes, and a direct RSS feed is also available. We also have a regular email newsletter which you can sign up to here.